ecancermedicalscience

Research

The analytical validation of the Oncotype DX Recurrence Score assay

26 Sep 2016
Frederick L Baehner

In vitro diagnostic multivariate index assays are highly complex molecular assays that can provide clinically actionable information regarding the underlying tumour biology and facilitate personalised treatment. These assays are only useful in clinical practice if all of the following are established: analytical validation (i.e., how accurately/reliably the assay measures the molecular characteristics), clinical validation (i.e., how consistently/accurately the test detects/predicts the outcomes of interest), and clinical utility (i.e., how likely the test is to significantly improve patient outcomes). In considering the use of these assays, clinicians often focus primarily on the clinical validity/utility; however, the analytical validity of an assay (e.g., its accuracy, reproducibility, and standardisation) should also be evaluated and carefully considered. This review focuses on the rigorous analytical validation and performance of the Oncotype DX® Breast Cancer Assay, which is performed at the Central Clinical Reference Laboratory of Genomic Health, Inc. The assay process includes tumour tissue enrichment (if needed), RNA extraction, gene expression quantitation (using a gene panel consisting of 16 cancer genes plus 5 reference genes and quantitative realtime RT-PCR), and an automated computer algorithm to produce a Recurrence Score® result (scale: 0–100). This review presents evidence showing that the Recurrence Score result reported for each patient falls within a tight clinically relevant confidence interval. Specifically, the review discusses how the development of the assay was designed to optimise assay performance, presents data supporting its analytical validity, and describes the quality control and assurance programmes that ensure optimal test performance over time.

Related Articles

Ashutosh Mishra, Amit Kumar, Ajay Gogia, Chinmay Bagla, Gajendra Pandit, Jyoti Sharma, Jyoutishman Saikia, Rohan Kapoor, D N Sharma, Atul Batra, Surendra Saini, Supriya Mallick, Nishkarsh Gupta, Brajesh Ratre, Ruchi Rathore, Sandeep Mathur, Sunil Kumar, Suryanarayana Deo
Imad Barjij, Sarah Naciri, Sihame Lkhoyaali, Saoussane Kharmoum, Hanane Inrhaouen, Ibrahim Elghissassi, Saber Boutayeb, Hind Mrabti, Hassan Errihani
Moushumi Suryavanshi, Prashant Mehta, Manoj Kumar, Saphalta Bhagmar, Vidit Kapoor, Dushyant Kumar, Sweta Mishra, Bhawna Chauhan
Maria Lucila González Donna, Eliza Ramirez Cabrera, Andrea Magali del Valle Ochelli, Lucia Ayala Albertini, Lucas Coradini, Verónica Alejandra Livieres Alayón, Iván Garrigoza Garcete, Cinthia Gauna Colas, Maria Luisa Cabañas León, Jabibi Noguera, Gladys Estigarribia, Alejandro Frydman, Carlos Palmes, Santiago Leguizamon, Matias Rodrigo Chacon, Federico Waisberg
Hafssa El Hilali, Nassiba Bahra, Sanae Guennouni, Chaymae Chbihi, Samia El Hakym, Diango Keita, Sara Nejjari, Abir Oufrid, Oumaima Siyouri, Lamiae Amaadour, Karima Oualla, Zineb Benbrahim, Touria Bouhafa, Nawfel Mellas, Samira El Fakir, Samia Arifi