Expanding clinical trial eligibility criteria: Risks and solutions

Share :
Published: 11 Jun 2019
Views: 1831
Rating:
Save
Dr Jorge Nieva - Keck School of Medicine of USC, Los Angeles, USA

Dr Jorge Nieva speaks to ecancer at the 2019 American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) Annual Meeting about a study which demonstrated the need to amend eligibility criteria for patients with advanced NSCLC in clinical trials.

He emphasises that these inclusion and exclusion criteria must change, as many patients are excluded from participating in clinical trials.

Dr Nieva also discusses the risks associated with expanding clinical trial criteria, which include allowing more patients with renal dysfunction, brain metastases and other significant co-morbidities to participate in these trials. To counteract this, he mentions some methods that can objectively stratify this larger patient population.

He concludes by describing a current clinical trial which uses digital tools to objectively quantify performance status in early-stage clinical trials.

 

LBA108 is a very important study. It looked at real world evidence to look at how inclusion criteria and exclusion criteria are needing to change. We exclude far too many patients from clinical trial participation and over the last twenty years we’ve seen the number of inclusion and exclusion criteria for enrolling into clinical trial grow rapidly. LBA108 shows us that it’s possible by modifying inclusion criteria that we can make clinical trials available to a larger percentage of the population but, of course, there are going to be risks.

As we allow more patients with worse renal function, patients who have brain metastases and other significant comorbidities into clinical trials we’re going to find that we’re enrolling a population that’s going to be slightly sicker. So when we do that we’re going to find that the rates of adverse events and serious adverse events are likely going to increase because we know that sicker patients have more adverse events. It’s going to be particularly important if the findings from LBA108 are instituted throughout the oncology community that we have some way of objectively stratifying patients according to illness. There are many ways of doing it – we can do it with comorbidity indexes we can do it with a global understanding of other illnesses but we can also do it using digital tools and technology that allow us to quantify performance status in ways that are objective, to better stratify the patient populations and really understand whether toxicities associated with new drugs being tested in clinical trials are reflections of the actual toxicity of the drug or whether they’re simply reflections of the comorbidities that the patients have. Teasing out the difference between drug-related and disease-related toxicities that occur on studies is going to need to be a major effort of the pharma industry over the next ten years.

We’ve instituted a clinical trial at USC, the Precision Performance Status study, where we’re looking at all of our patients enrolling in early stage clinical trials and using digital tools like 3D cameras as well as wearable devices in order to objectively quantify performance status.

Related Videos

Digital pathology superior to manual SP263 PD-L1 TC scoring for stage II-IIIA high PD-L1 expression NSCLC

Prof Martin Reck - German Center of Lung Research, Grosshansdorf, Germany
Digital pathology superior to manual SP263 PD-L1 TC scoring for stage II-IIIA high PD-L1 expression NSCLC ( Prof Martin Reck - German Center of Lung Research, Grosshansdorf, Germany )
10 Apr 2025

ESMO and WCLC: Latest developments in EGFR mutated NSCLC

Dr Matthew Krebs, Dr Antonio Passaro, Dr Enriqueta Felip and Prof Pascale Tomasini
ESMO and WCLC: Latest developments in EGFR mutated NSCLC ( Dr Matthew Krebs, Dr Antonio Passaro, Dr Enriqueta Felip and Prof Pascale Tomasini )
18 Oct 2024

Predicting tumour mutations from pathology images may help increase personalised medicine utilisation

Dr Rom Leidner - Providence Cancer Institute, Portland, USA
Predicting tumour mutations from pathology images may help increase personalised medicine utilisation ( Dr Rom Leidner - Providence Cancer Institute, Portland, USA )
17 Oct 2024

Tusamitamab ravtansine versus docetaxel in previously treated advanced nonsquamous NSCLC: Results from phase 3 CARMEN-LC03 trial

Prof Benjamin Besse - Gustave Roussy, Paris, France
Tusamitamab ravtansine versus docetaxel in previously treated advanced nonsquamous NSCLC: Results from phase 3 CARMEN-LC03 trial ( Prof Benjamin Besse - Gustave Roussy, Paris, France )
1 Oct 2024

TROP2 expression measured by QCS is a promising predictor of clinical outcomes in patients with mNSCLC

Dr Marina Garassino - University of Chicago, Chicago, USA
TROP2 expression measured by QCS is a promising predictor of clinical outcomes in patients with mNSCLC ( Dr Marina Garassino - University of Chicago, Chicago, USA )
26 Sep 2024

Innovative treatments for solid tumours – TTFields as a therapeutic modality

Dr Giuseppe Lombardi, Dr Helen Bulbeck, Prof Dean Fennell and Dr Tadeja Urbanic-Purkart
Innovative treatments for solid tumours – TTFields as a therapeutic modality ( Dr Giuseppe Lombardi, Dr Helen Bulbeck, Prof Dean Fennell and Dr Tadeja Urbanic-Purkart )
2 Nov 2023

Feasibility and safety of boost at 74 Gy based on interim FDG-PET during thoracic radio-chemotherapy for NSCLC patients

Prof Gerard Zalcman - Université de Paris, Paris, France
Feasibility and safety of boost at 74 Gy based on interim FDG-PET during thoracic radio-chemotherapy for NSCLC patients ( Prof Gerard Zalcman - Université de Paris, Paris, France )
27 Oct 2023

Adagrasib shows durable clinical benefit in advanced KRAS-mutant NSCLC

Dr Shirish Gadgeel - Henry Ford Cancer Institute, Detroit, USA
Adagrasib shows durable clinical benefit in advanced KRAS-mutant NSCLC ( Dr Shirish Gadgeel - Henry Ford Cancer Institute, Detroit, USA )
17 Oct 2023

The 5-year long-term outcomes of radiation technique for locally advanced NSCLC

Dr Stephen Chun - MD Anderson, Houston, USA
The 5-year long-term outcomes of radiation technique for locally advanced NSCLC ( Dr Stephen Chun - MD Anderson, Houston, USA )
14 Sep 2023