Acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) cells from patients whose cancers did not respond to CD19-targeted CAR T therapy had gene regulation signatures that could potentially facilitate treatment resistance, according to results presented at the AACR Annual Meeting 2022.
“We identified a signature of nonresponse that is present and detectable prior to treatment,” said Katherine Masih, an NIH-Cambridge scholar in the Genetics Branch at the National Cancer Institute, who presented the study.
“The data support that these leukaemias are relatively plastic and exhibit multi-lineage potential, similar to stem cells, which we suspect allows them to more rapidly adapt to the evolutionary pressures of CD19 CAR T cells,” she added.
CAR T-cell therapy is a type of immunotherapy in which immune cells called T cells are harvested from a patient, reprogrammed to target cancer cells, and infused back into the patient to fight the cancer.
A common CAR T-cell target is the receptor CD19; however, cancer cells can mutate CD19 or suppress its expression to develop CAR T resistance. While CD19 expression is currently one of the few biomarkers of potential CAR T response, not all patients who develop resistance lose CD19 expression.
“Our study is one of the few studies looking at CD19-independent sources of primary nonresponse to CAR T therapy,” said Javed Khan, MD, senior author of the study and deputy chief of the Genetics Branch at the National Cancer Institute, explaining that some cells are intrinsically predisposed to treatment resistance.
“The main purpose was to identify pre-existing, leukaemia-intrinsic mechanisms of resistance.”
The researchers acquired pretreatment bone marrow samples from the PLAT-02 clinical trial, performed at Seattle Children’s Hospital in collaboration with Rebecca Gardner, MD and Rimas Orentas, PhD.
The samples were collected from seven patients who experienced a complete remission following CD19-targeted CAR T therapy and seven patients who did not have a response, defined by continued evidence of circulating leukaemia cells 63 days post-treatment.
They comprehensively characterised the leukaemia cells using several cell profiling methods, such as whole-exome sequencing, RNA sequencing of the bulk cell population, single-cell RNA sequencing, array-based methylation analysis, and ATAC-seq, an assay that locates regions of accessible chromatin that frequently indicate increased gene expression.
The researchers identified three notable features that differentiated the gene regulatory mechanisms of CAR T-resistant leukaemia cells from CAR T-responsive leukaemia cells. One was a pattern of DNA methylation, a regulatory mark that decreases gene expression, associated with a stem cell-like phenotype.
“We observed hypermethylation around genes known to be repressed in embryonic cells and cancer stem cells,” Masih said.
Masih and colleagues observed similar results when they examined the DNA accessibility profiles of the leukaemia cells.
The regions of open chromatin characteristic of CAR T-cell resistant leukaemia were associated with stem cell proliferation and resembled patterns found in haematopoietic progenitor cells, including haematopoietic stem cells and progenitors of myeloid cells, a different class of blood cells associated with acute myeloid leukaemia (AML).
Khan said that a switch from a lymphoid to a myeloid lineage has been observed as a mechanism of resistance to CD19-CAR T therapy.
“Interestingly, we saw subpopulations of cells expressing both lymphoid and myeloid markers, indicating that the epigenomes of some nonresponsive leukaemias may contain a hybrid population of cells with a hybrid of ALL and AML epigenomes,” Khan said.
“Our data suggest that these leukaemias, characterised by both lymphoid and myeloid-specific accessible regions, are likely less differentiated than responsive leukaemias.
”The researchers also identified decreased expression of genes involved in antigen presentation and processing, pathways that are crucial for mounting an immune response, in cells that did not respond to CAR T therapy. Decreased antigen presentation could indicate that, even if leukaemia cells continue to express CD19, they may not effectively process additional immune targets.
“Our next steps would be to recapitulate this clinical phenomenon in a mouse model, using different subpopulations of leukaemia cells, and then examine if we can overcome this primary resistance with combinatorial or alternative therapies,” Masih said.
“This study allowed us to not only identify potential clinical biomarkers, but to test the logistical feasibility of using these profiling approaches to impact patient care,” Khan added.
“We hope that one day, screening for this phenotype could allow clinicians to identify patients whose leukaemias are unlikely to respond prior to therapy and provide alternative therapies to improve outcomes for these patients.”
We are an independent charity and are not backed by a large company or society. We raise every penny ourselves to improve the standards of cancer care through education. You can help us continue our work to address inequalities in cancer care by making a donation.
Any donation, however small, contributes directly towards the costs of creating and sharing free oncology education.
Together we can get better outcomes for patients by tackling global inequalities in access to the results of cancer research.
Thank you for your support.