ecancermedicalscience

Review

Is there any benefit to particles over photon radiotherapy?

9 Dec 2019
Maria E Goossens, Marc van den Bulcke, Thierry Gevaert, Lydie Meheus, Dirk Verellen, Jean-Marc Cosset, Guy Storme

Particle, essentially, proton radiotherapy (RT) could provide some benefits over photon RT, especially in reducing the side effects of RT. We performed a systematic review to identify the performed randomised clinical trials (RCTs) and ongoing RCTs comparing particle RT with photon therapy. So far, there are no results available from phase 3 RCTs comparing particle RT with photon therapy. Furthermore, the results on side effects comparing proton and carbon ion beam RT with photon RT do vary. The introduction of new techniques in photon RT, such as image-guided RT (IGRT), intensity-modulated RT (IMRT), volumetric arc therapy (VMAT) and stereotactic body RT (SBRT) was already effective in reducing side effects. At present, the lack of evidence limits the indications for proton and carbon ion beam RTs and makes the particle RT still experimental.

Related Articles

Monali Swain, Sarbani Ghosh-Laskar, Lachlan McDowell, Christina Henson, Pierluigi Bonomo, Sadhana Kannan, Timothy Malouff, Akihiro Homma, Alexander Rühle, Anna Lee, Francesca Caparrotti, James Bates, Jorgen Johansen, Juliette Thariat, Marco Ferrari, Miguel Mayo-Yáñez, Sarah Hamilton, Sue S Yom, Hisham Mehanna, Petr Szturz
Catalina Vargas Añazco, Álvaro Torres Soto, Renata Soto Díaz, Martín Urra, Maite Azócar, Mauricio Camus Appuhn, Francisco Dominguez Covarrubias, César Sánchez Rojel, Francisco Acevedo Claros
Ahmed Sohaib, Enas Elkhouly, Gehad Elsheikh, Mahmoud Sweid, Alaa Shawkat, Hany Moawad, Muhammad Abulfadl, Amira Hegazy
Meghal Prajapati, Anil Kumar Goel, Yamini Patel, Divyeshkumar Rana, S Lokesh, Pooja Panchal, Dhruv Rathod, Chandramouli Ramalingam, Kondeti Ajay Kumar
Mahama Jato Asuma, Akoto Yaw Omari Sasu, Alhassan Faisal, Akulibile James, Addae Bernard Mensah